Paranormal Underground

Explore the Unexplained

twitterfacebookyoutubeyoutuberss

And You Know this Because?

by Karen Frazier, Managing Editor
Paranormal Underground Magazine

I get just a little bit tired of paranormal know-it-alls. You find them everywhere. On forums, in blog comments, just walking down the street. You know who they are – you’d recognize them if you saw them.

Typically they start whatever statement that they are about to make with, “I don’t want to hurt anybody’s feelings, BUT….”

And then they go on. And on, and on and on. They take any piece of anomalous evidence that others might have and they tell you exactly what it is. But all is not lost, because they then go on to tell you that if you are just like them and you work hard, however, you too can capture REAL HONEST TO GOODNESS PARANORMAL EVIDENCE!!!

“Oh that’s totally faked….not at all like the evidence that I have. Maybe if you work hard you can be just like me and get genuine evidence. Keep trying.”

~or~

“Come on – that big black shadow in the exact shape of a human isn’t anything paranormal. It is your uncle’s, best friend’s, third cousin who is all dressed in black. If you want to get a real ghost picture you have to work at it like I do. Here, take a look at this orb. Now that’s a real ghost picture.”

It varies – but it you get the idea. I’m talking about the person who looks at everyone else’s evidence and tells you exactly what it is (not what it could be – not what they believe it to be, but what it IS) and then go on to tell you that really the only way for you to ever get real evidence like they have is to be a real ghost hunter who works very hard like they do.

Whenever I hear someone say, “Oh that’s not paranormal it’s _____________.”

I always want to ask them, “And you know this because???”

Paranormal know-it-alls, listen up. I’m all for exploring alternative explanations for pieces of evidence. I’m all for sharing information and ideas. I’m all for trying to figure out what evidence could be and what it likely isn’t. But you don’t know any more than any other person what that strange anomaly really is. You may have ideas and you may have guesses, but if you weren’t there, then how can you know? Heck, even if you were there, how can you know? And why is it that you know that your orbs and rods and recorded garbled whispers are truly paranormal when every other piece of paranormal evidence you come across captured by another isn’t? After all, your evidence could be dust, bugs, light anomalies or some guy scraping his shoe along the floor in such a way that it sounds just like a whisper. Even if the hair stood up on your arm in the few hours before you captured said orb/rod/inaudible whisper.

Here’s the big secret to the paranormal. Nobody knows. We only guess. We guess at our methods. We guess at interpretations of evidence. We come up with potential explanations. We don’t know, and we can’t know, and to say that you do know – about how everyone else’s evidence doesn’t and can’t measure up in the face of yours – well that’s just plain silliness at best and delusional self-glorification at worst.

It makes us all look bad – like a bunch of bullying, back biting, infighting, self-glorifying nincompoops who can’t see the forest through the trees.

Nope – nobody dissed my evidence today. I’m not even talking to one person in particular. Most of the people I know and deal with on a regular basis are pretty darn objective and helpful. Heck – I’m the first to tell you that the anomalous things I capture may just have rational, logical explanations, and I’m happy to seek them out. Bring it on. Let’s discuss them. Let’s discuss methods, techniques, evidence and everything else. But let’s do it with an open minds and a spirit of cooperation. Let’s find a way that we can have discussions where we don’t have to be right or know it all. Because we don’t. As a matter of fact, we don’t really know much of anything. And if we continue having to be right at all costs and at the expense of everyone else in the community, then we never will.

Enjoy reading Karen’s blog? Her new book, Avalanche of Spirits: The Ghosts of Wellington> is now available. Click here to buy.

Comments (6)
  1. Justin / Reply January 25, 2010 at 1:02 pm

    This is a really good point you make. I have seen these kinda people everywhere and I understand skeptics but if everything is fake, then why are they in this business? The reason we like ghost hunting so much is because we like to find evidence that is unexplainable.

  2. Bryan / Reply January 25, 2010 at 4:32 pm

    Are there those who criticize everybody else’s analytical skills while assuring everyone that their evidence is solid? Sure there is, but by far the most problematic aspect of the paranormal community is the absolute refusal to engage in a logical and reasonable critical analysis of their own data. It seems the community, in large, is more concerned with proving something that they already believe to be true than to uncover any truths regarding certain phenomena. Ninety percent of so-called “evidence” I have seen propagated on the internet have perfectly natural explanations. If they have natural explanations, they are not anomalous. However, many in this field, don’t want to learn how to distinguish between natural and supernatural phenomena, unfortunately. They will defend their unfounded claims to the very end regardless of any other sound explanations presented to them. So while I understand the frustration of dealing with somebody who refuses to accept the idea that a particular phenomena may have no natural explanation, I am equally frustrated with those who refuse to entertain the notion that something may have a perfectly natural explanation.

  3. Karen Frazier / Reply January 25, 2010 at 4:42 pm

    Yep, Bryan. Both are an issue. I’ve covered the other kind in other blogs. :)

  4. Dave / Reply January 25, 2010 at 7:07 pm

    I am with Bryan on this one.

  5. Dreamsinger / Reply January 26, 2010 at 3:54 pm

    This is exactly why I’ve always championed methods that don’t hunt anomalies. Anomalies are subject to interpretation and cannot be identified. Just as in math, you can’t solve the equations if there are too many variables. This is why I always ask investigators “why bother?” So you have 200 EVPs recorded, or a hundred hours of video anomalies recorded. What good are they? They could be paranormal, but they could also be normal. You’re just as well off at flipping a coin as trying to draw a conclusion as to what they are.

    American Paranormal did more in one experiment than I’ve seen the anomaly hunters do in over 100 years. They established the premise that infra-sound could play a big part into what people experience in some locations. They use methods that gain results and do not try to speculate over what some anomaly may be, and they do not go in to try and prove or disprove (debunk) paranormal activity. They simply seek to establish what is, and show what variables need to be screened out when conducting later searches for what is.

    This is what I’ve advocated for years. “What ifs” and decreeing “Science doesn’t know everything” are simply excuses that never produce any truth because they don’t progress anywhere. “What ifs” are a great starting point but without constructing a testable hypothesis they only manifest into theories such as “ghosts create cold spots by drawing in thermal energy to manifest.” As for those who point out that science doesn’t know everything I guess they miss the point that if it did then we wouldn’t have to search for understanding about ghosts and the paranormal since science would already have those answers. Basically it’s a red herring argument to draw attention from the fact that paranormal investigation as it currently is in the paranormal community hasn’t discovered anything or revealed any truths.

    Now the big question is will the paranormal community pay attention to what American Paranormal has revealed, and will they see how to conduct investigations that yield beneficial data instead of hunting anomalies? I would hope so, but given their track record I don’t think so. Especially when it comes to the ParaCelebs. I’m pretty certain they’ll pull out their trunk load of ad hominem attacks, red herring arguments, and do everything they can to dissuade others that science hasn’t shown anything, just so they can keep selling their goods and wares.

  6. Gloria Grimaldi / Reply March 30, 2010 at 10:20 pm

    Yep, let’s discuss them, let’s talk, and measure the evidence you have and they have, and stop acting like they know it all. you hit it on the nail when you said “we really don’t know”, you only know what it let’s you see, and I don’t care what kind of new scientific gadgets they have it still won’t let you know all the truth, we are lucky to know what we know now. I am a chicken, see, I will not go out there like you and go looking for evidence. I rather investicate through t.v or internent or books. I have seen a lot of people out there who will not believe it, even if it stares at them in the face, and the ones who act like they know all there is to know and actullly they don’t..I would love to see them stay over night and experience the true fact of fear. some are lucky and get all of this great evidence and some don’t, it does not mean that they are better it means they where lucky.




Leave a Comment

Shopping Cart
  • No products in the cart.
12-Month Digital Subscription Only $19.99!
Get 12 digital issues of Paranormal Underground magazine. We’ll e-mail each new issue to you every month. Subscribe now and save 15%!
Subscribe Now for Updates
Video Gallery
Close Box

First Time back?
You must reset your password
to log in to the new site.

A password will be e-mailed to you.

Please enter your username or email address.
You will receive a link to reset the password via email.